657a Publication | Doherty Website

The Univeristy of Melbourne The Royal Melbourne Hopspital

A joint venture between The University of Melbourne and The Royal Melbourne Hospital

Publication

Evaluating the implementability of Antibiotic Surgical Prophylaxis guidelines


Authors:

  • Ierano, Courtney
  • Ayton, Darshini
  • Peel, Trisha
  • Marshall, Caroline
  • Thursky, Karin

Details:

Infection, Disease & Health, Volume 25, Issue 1, 2020-02-29

Article Link: Click here

Background Current Australian data highlight guideline noncompliant prescribing of antimicrobials for surgical prophylaxis. The study aim was to evaluate the implementability of the Australian national surgical prophylaxis (SAP) guidelines to identify facilitators for and barriers to compliance. Methods Key stakeholders appraised the surgical prophylaxis guidelines using the GuideLine Implementability Appraisal (GLIA) tool. Questions with 100% agreement for the response ‘Yes’ were identified as facilitators and those with 100% agreement for ‘No’, a barrier. Questions that did not receive 100% agreement, but had a majority (40–60%) ‘Yes’ or ‘No’ consensus were considered as borderline facilitators and barriers respectively. Results Ten appraisals were completed. Guideline recommendations were rated as easily identifiable and concise and were thus facilitators for implementation. The ability to measure guideline adherence and outcomes, and recommendations that were consistent with guideline user abilities and beliefs were also identified as facilitators. Borderline facilitators related to the clarity of the recommendations and whether they were explicit in what to do and in what circumstances. Evidence quality underpinning recommendations (validity), inflexibility of recommendations (flexibility) and the lack of patient data at the point of use (computability) were identified as borderline barriers to implementation. No recommendation reached agreement as being a barrier. Conclusion The GLIA appraisal demonstrated overall implementability of the current Australian national surgical prophylaxis guidelines. Facilitators (i.e., measurability) and borderline facilitators highlight strengths of the current guideline. Borderline barriers (i.e., validity, flexibility and computability) may negatively impact upon implementability. Guideline developers should consider these dimensions to optimise guideline uptake and consequently patient care.

0